Jeopardy! Masters Recap – Tuesday, May 9, 2023 (Game 2)


Are you looking for today’s regular-game recap? Find it here!

Are you looking for the recap for tonight’s first Masters game? Find it here!

Warning: This page contains spoilers for the May 9, 2023, second game of Jeopardy! Masters — please do not scroll down if you wish to avoid being spoiled. It will be updated alongside the Eastern Time airing of the show, beginning at about 8:30 PM Eastern.

This game’s Jeopardy! Masters contestants:

Matt Amodio, a postdoctoral researcher from Cambridge, Massachusetts (0 points)
Matt Amodio on Jeopardy! Masters
James Holzhauer, a self-described game show villain from Las Vegas, Nevada (3 points)
James Holzhauer on Jeopardy! Masters
Andrew He, a software developer from San Francisco, California (3 points)
Andrew He on Jeopardy! Masters

Andy’s Pregame Thoughts:

After their victories last night, James Holzhauer and Andrew He will lock horns; today’s game will absolutely come down to the Daily Doubles, who finds them, and when. Unfortunately, Matt Amodio probably got the worst possible draw for the second night—he seemed to be lacking confidence, and having to play James Holzhauer and Andrew He will likely not be particularly helpful for his buzzer timing or his confidence. If Matt was to pull out a result—and he’s certainly capable of doing so—it would be huge for his Masters chances.


PSA: The best way to keep COVID-19 at bay (and keep Jeopardy! producing new episodes) is for everybody to get their vaccinations as soon as they can, including any boosters as recommended. When wearing a mask, please ensure that your mask covers both your nose and your mouth.

Are you going on the show and looking for information about how to bet in Final Jeopardy? Check out my new Betting Strategy 101 page!

I recently updated my tournament wildcard models with as much tournament data as I’ve been able to find! If you’re playing in a tournament, you’ll want to check this out!

(Content continues below)

Do you appreciate the work I do here on The Jeopardy! Fan? Would you like to make a one-time contribution to the site? You may do so here!

You can find game-by-game stats here at The Jeopardy! Fan of all players, including Matt Amodio, Jonathan Fisher, Amy Schneider, Mattea Roach, Ryan Long, and Cris Pannullo, that have won 10 or more games on Jeopardy!


We have many new offerings at The Jeopardy! Fan Online Store! Proceeds from the sale of the “Doctor Oz’s Fast-Acting Snake Oil Elixir” T-shirt are being donated to The Trevor Project:


You can now listen to Alex Trebek-hosted Jeopardy! episodes from TuneIn Radio without leaving The Jeopardy! Fan — listen now!


Looking to find out who won Jeopardy! Masters today? Today’s results will be posted once the show airs!


Game Recap & Tonight’s Game Stats:

Looking to find out who won Jeopardy! Masters today? Here’s the Tuesday, May 9, 2023 Jeopardy! Masters (game 2) by the numbers, along with a recap:

Jeopardy! Round:

(Categories: The Other Masters; Libraries; Overwrought History; Ethiopia; You Speak Latin, Right?; Need! Coffee! Now!)

In a round that saw 30 correct responses, Matt got to the Daily Double, but James battled back to take a slim lead after 30 clues. Only 2,400 separated first from last, though!

Statistics after the Jeopardy round:

James 14 correct 0 incorrect
Matt 7 correct 0 incorrect
Andrew 9 correct 1 incorrect

Scores after the Jeopardy! Round:

James $7,600
Matt $6,800
Andrew $5,200

Today’s interviews:

Matt would like to thank his girlfriend for a movie poster and getting the Taylor Swift clue correct.
James is very involved with Project 150 in Las Vegas.
Andrew got James Holzhauer to take off his shoes and socks.

Double Jeopardy! Round:

(Categories: Please Look Through The Telescope; Rhymingly Named Celebs; Literature; Contronyms; A New Coat; “Of” Paint)

Matt and James both went all in on their Daily Doubles—surprise, surprise—and they both ended up in a dead heat going into Final! What will happen?

Statistics after Double Jeopardy:

James 27 correct 1 incorrect
Matt 16 correct 2 incorrect
Andrew 13 correct 1 incorrect

Scores going into Final:

James $28,400
Matt $28,400
Andrew $9,600

Final Jeopardy category: Western Hemisphere History

Final Jeopardy! clue: In 1915 the assassination of President Sam brought Uncle Sam to this country, beginning a 19-year military occupation


Correct response: What is Haiti?


Final was a Triple Stumper, though James crossed out the correct response—but Matt went with a small bet and has won this match! 3 points to Matt, 1 to Andrew, and 0 to James!

Tonight’s results:

Andrew $9,600 – $0 = $9,600 (What is baby we got a game goin’)
James $28,400 – $28,400 = $0 (What is Haiti Nicaragua?)
Matt $28,400 – $1,000 = $27,400 (What Nicaragua?)


Jeopardy! Masters results for Game 2 on May 9, 2023

Jeopardy! Masters Standings:

1st: Andrew He (4 points, 1 win, 41 correct, 31,400 Coryat)
2nd: James Holzhauer (3 points, 1 win, 49 correct, 38,400 Coryat)
3rd: Mattea Roach (3 points, 1 win, 32 correct, 22,400 Coryat)
4th: Matt Amodio (3 points, 1 win, 29 correct, 22,000 Coryat)
5th: Amy Schneider (2 points, 0 wins, 31 correct, 24,000 Coryat)
6th: Sam Buttrey (1 point, 0 wins, 38 correct, 24,600 Coryat)

Tomorrow’s match-ups:

Game 1: James Holzhauer, Amy Schneider, Sam Buttrey
Game 2: Andrew He, Mattea Roach, Matt Amodio


Other Miscellaneous Game Statistics:

Daily Double locations:

1) ETHIOPIA $800 (clue #7)
Matt 2600 +2600 (Andrew 800 James 2000)
2) “OF” PAINT $800 (clue #9)
Matt 13200 +13200 (Andrew 8000 James 8400)
3) A NEW COAT $1600 (clue #14, $16400 left on board)
James 10400 +10400 (Andrew 8000 Matt 25200)
Overall Daily Double Efficiency for this game: 300

Clue Selection by Row, Before Daily Doubles Found:

J! Round:
Andrew 5 5
James 4 3
Matt 5 5 4*

DJ! Round:
Andrew 3 5 4
James 4 2 2 5 3 4*
Matt 4 3 5 2* 3

Average Row of Clue Selection, Before Daily Doubles Found:

Matt 3.88
Andrew 4.40
James 3.38

Game Stats:

Matt $14,200 Coryat, 16 correct, 2 incorrect, 28.07% in first on buzzer (16/57), 0/0 on rebound attempts (on 2 rebound opportunities)
Andrew $9,600 Coryat, 13 correct, 1 incorrect, 22.81% in first on buzzer (13/57), 1/1 on rebound attempts (on 3 rebound opportunities)
James $19,600 Coryat, 27 correct, 1 incorrect, 45.61% in first on buzzer (26/57), 1/1 on rebound attempts (on 3 rebound opportunities)
Combined Coryat Score: $43,400
Lach Trash: $6,000 (on 4 Triple Stumpers)
Coryat lost to incorrect responses (less double-correct responses): $4,600

Player Statistics:

Andrew He, career statistics:

339 correct, 45 incorrect
18/21 on rebound attempts (on 57 rebound opportunities)
35.09% in first on buzzer (320/912)
21/27 on Daily Doubles (Net Earned: $92,800)
6/16 in Final Jeopardy
Average Coryat: $16,463
To win: 17.6%
To make finals: 52.6%
To make semifinals: 75.0%

James Holzhauer, career statistics:

1550 correct, 66 incorrect
45/49 on rebound attempts (on 99 rebound opportunities)
53.61% in first on buzzer (1426/2660)
87/94 on Daily Doubles (Net Earned: $751,988)
41/47 in Final Jeopardy
Average Coryat: $27,451
To win: 25.4%
To make finals: 74.0%
To make semifinals: 94.6%

Matt Amodio, career statistics:

1372 correct, 141 incorrect
58/67 on rebound attempts (on 132 rebound opportunities)
53.84% in first on buzzer (1310/2433)
82/92 on Daily Doubles (Net Earned: $329,800)
31/43 in Final Jeopardy
Average Coryat: $26,214
To win: 17.8%
To make finals: 51.0%
To make semifinals: 66.8%

Andy’s Thoughts:

Final Jeopardy! wagering suggestions:

(Scores: James $28,400 Matt $28,400 Andrew $9,600)

Andrew: Just don’t go all in. (Actual bet: $0)

James: Bet either everything or nothing. (Actual bet: $28,400)

Matt: Bet either everything or nothing. (Actual bet: $1,000)

Contestant photo credit: jeopardy.com

When commenting, please note that all comments on The Jeopardy! Fan must be in compliance with the Site Comment Policy.

If you are going to quote any information from this page or this website, attribution is required.


Have you had a chance to listen to our podcast game show, Complete The List, yet? Check it out! It’s also available on Apple Podcasts.



18 Comments on "Jeopardy! Masters Recap – Tuesday, May 9, 2023 (Game 2)"

  1. Riley O. | May 9, 2023 at 9:04 pm |

    I’m pulling for Matt in this tournament so you can imagine my excitement when he pulled through with this epic win. I can’t wait to watch tomorrow’s games!!

  2. wataya_noboru | May 9, 2023 at 9:05 pm |

    Love to see Matt get his buzzer mojo back.

    I checked the box scores, and he actually had the most buzzer attempts of all players yesterday (50), but only got in 28% of the time compared to Amy’s 39& and Andrew’s 57%(!).

    He’s too good to go quietly here, so it’s awesome to see him make a game of it against James (I’m sure Matt himself enjoyed it too, especially after James needled him on Twitter 😉

    • With the same six players in 20 consecutive games, moving around in location [podium 1, 2, or 3], after it is all over it would be interesting to compare the buzzer percentages for each player in relation to their podium location each time. Of course that would be affected by the categories and the other two players, but with them all being so well matched, this would be the best time to see if there is even a hint of one buzzer maybe being easier to use than another. I actually think “probably not”, but still, the results would possibly be interesting (or proof to skeptics that that is not the case).

      Something similar that I think would be interesting to compare is buzzer skill vs palm size, but I don’t expect to ever get that chance. [I can’t help but think that it plays at least a small element in the number of men winners vs women winners, but some men have kind of petite hands, I guess.]

  3. Bill Vollmer | May 9, 2023 at 9:17 pm |

    I love the interplay on these prime time games.Like Mattea’s comment on the Sgt. Schultz ?answer” in today’s first game. And, if anyone thinks these players aren’t taking this Masters competition seriously, just look at Sam’s reaction to a wrong answer in today’s first game, and, James looking like he wanted to kick himself for his wrong responses this game.
    In both Final Jeopardys on tonighta ahow, I had no idea. Never read “The Girl With the Dragon Tatoo, and, if I once knew that th4 US had once occupied Hati, I;ve forgotten it.

    • Michael+Johnston | May 9, 2023 at 10:03 pm |

      Re – Haiti occupied by US. I knew it had happened, but I didn’t know when or even think of it. The name of President Sam rang no bells.

      Current FJ streak: 2L

  4. I completely and totally echo your comment about where this stands among the greatest games of Jeopardy ever. This is what Masters is all about – amazing gameplay from amazing contestants. This was also the first game to make me scream so loudly that I wouldn’t be totally shocked to receive a noise complaint 🙂

    And going off of Twitter, it’s nice to see James and Matt actually develop a bit of a friendship from playing together. It’s awesome to see that all the contestants are getting along and actually becoming friends with each other.

    Ken’s comment at the end couldn’t have been more accurate. This was easily the best episode of Jeopardy! ever. Actually, scratch that. Probably the best episode of any syndicated TV game show ever.

  5. The only reason this may NOT be the greatest game of all time, is that no one got Final J! correct. And that surprised me! a) Haiti is a republic, just like the US, and has a President, just like the US (since 1805, minus the years in question), and b) When Ken pronounced President Sam’s name DIFFERENTLY than “Uncle Sam” that was a PRETTY clear clue he was going for a French-speaking country. Given the rest of the context, not that hard? Still, the Double J tie (with the top two players each getting a “true” daily double, and coming down to the “easy” clues) was a wowser!

    • Ken’s pronunciation was the same as the Spanish pronunciation of “Sam”.

      • The first couple Google responses seemed to imply that “Sam” sounded the same in Spanish or English. Apparently not? It’s “Saam” in both English and French. mea culpa!

    • I would’ve guessed Panama based upon the timeline near construction of the Canal. Couldn’t really tell French from Spanish there either.

  6. George Brett | May 9, 2023 at 9:46 pm |

    What are the rules for ties in these Master tournaments?

  7. Just finished the season of the Revolutions podcast on the Haiti last week. Thanks, Mike!

  8. Congrats to both Mattea and Matt for getting the wins they needed to get off the schneid, going back to the TOC. This Masters tournament just got a lot more interesting!

  9. Feels like tonight showed why the Masters tournament exists! Take 6 incredible players, set up the gameplay in such a way that allows for variability etc., and you’ll get a chance to see all of them really shine!

  10. After two games, I’ve concluded one thing: These players are all basically even. I give a slight edge to James as he is the only player who has had the most correct responses in his two games.

  11. Andy, you might want to fix a typo. For the interviews you wrote “Matt would like to think his girlfriend” when I know you meant “thank”.

Comments are closed.